ATO Decision Impact Statements: Qantas and Barrow
by Jane Tu
The ATO today released Decision Impact Statements on the following cases:
- FCT v Qantas Airways Limited  HCA 41 - In that case, the High Court (by a 4-1 majority) allowed the Commissioner's appeal and held that Qantas was liable for GST on purchased airfares where the passenger did not turn up for the flight. In the Decision Impact Statement, the ATO broadly said the High Court's decision supported its position in various rulings issued. However, it said it will review and update various GST Rulings to take into account the reasoning of the High Court. In addition, the ATO said it will also contact various entities that had lodged notifications of entitlement to refund forms after the Full Federal Court's decision in the case, and ask whether they still intend to pursue a refund claim notwithstanding the High Court's decision.
- AAT Case  AATA 640, Re Barrow and FCT - In that case, the AAT allowed a taxpayer's objection against certain amended energy grants credit scheme claim assessments, net fuel amount assessments, and shortfall penalty assessments, but upheld the Commissioner's denial of other objections by the taxpayer. In the Decision Impact Statement, the ATO said the decision was one the Tribunal was entitled to make on the evidence before it and accords with the Commissioner's views on substantiation.